As I was reading "Safe Spaces" by August I becomes really distracted at times because I wasn't too intrigued by this authors writing style. I really liked that August was informative of the LGBT lifestyle and gave examples of teachers discriminating against students that are not heterosexual but the author never really said anything to pull my attention in. As I continued to read the article I read some of the students stories for example Maria. Maria is an "out" lesbian taking a Spanish class, and on her test she got back from her teacher she noticed the teacher marked wrong one of her answers. The question include " Do you have a sweetheart?" And Maria responded with " yo tenga una novia." Maria's response with "novia" was marked wrong because it is the female representation of sweetheart and next to it the teach put "novia" the male version of sweetheart. Maria was offended by this because her Spanish teacher just automatically marked it wrong because she was a girl and her sweetheart was supposed to be a boy, which in Maria's case it isn't. I tried to imagine myself as the teacher and wonder what I would do in a situation like this. What if I didn't know the student is gay? Is that my fault? My intentions wouldn't mean to offend her but if I had in any way I would have apologized and gave her back to points that she deserved because in her situation her answer to the question was correct. I then reflected on this article to my own life. I went to a Christian school for elementary school and I was really sheltered from the outside word. For example, when I had no idea what 92.3 pro FM was until 5th grade! My dad is also a State Trooper so he tried his best to hide the mess of the real world from me, my brother, and sister until we reached an appropriate age. When I switched to a public school in sixth grade I think I learned more about the "real world" than I did in school. I started learning this about myself, my friends, my town and especially my family. One day my dad had finally told me that my aunt, his sister, was a lesbian, it was as if so many things clicked at once. I had never given it a thought why she wasn't married, or why she didn't have a boyfriend, or why she occasionally brought friends that were girls over to my grandmothers house for dinner sometimes, until that moment. My dad and his family also grew up very religious and believed that being gay was wrong. Because of this it created a lot of turmoil between the two of them and we had actually lost connection with her for years, until my dad opened his heart and came to terms that it wasn't his life so why was he worried about it. I felt really bad for my aunt that he made her feel so ashamed for who she was and that she missed a lot of years of our lives for a reason that doesn't make us love her any less. I couldn't imagine my own family basically shunning me for who I was just because society and religion didn't think it was "right." My aunt is married now and the happiest I've ever seen her I'm glad that she can be who she is and happy in her own skin and that she could forgive my dad.
I thought that some of the discriminating teachers were downright cruel! I loved reading your story about your father and your aunt. I feel bad that you had grown up so sheltered as a child. I respect your dad's opinion. Lastly I want to say Hooray for your aunt for finding true love! Overall I enjoyed reading your blog.
ReplyDeleteSam I really enjoyed reading your reflection. I like the story you mentioned about Maria. That's so true, what if you didn't know? If the teacher did know then that is a different story but what if they didn't? Would the student go up and tell the teacher that in fact, she was correct on her test? I also liked how you told us about your Aunt and when it all made sense to you. Good reflection Sam!
ReplyDeleteI love your quote from Ellen!!! Literally, when I was writing my blog I didn't even think of her. But she's the best human in the world, so I loved that :) But I loved how you made personal connects with the text, it really made your piece more powerful!
ReplyDeleteI really like your story about your aunt, and about how your dad learned to be more accepting. If everyone could learn to be accepting like this, then maybe these problems would slowly begin to diminish. Good job!
ReplyDeleteI love your personal connections to this reading. I'm really glad you put that in there. It was very interesting and informative. I also love your pictures! Great post. :)
ReplyDeleteGood job! I really like how you included the story abut Maria. I feel like that's a tough situation for a teacher to be in. Also I think it was wrong for the teacher to assume that Maria had a boyfriend because she is a girl. I loved your personal story about your dad an you aunt. It would be great if people could be more accepting like him.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing your story here, Samantha.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you about the whole telling a child thier answer is wrong. I was so wrong on the teachers part. I love the picture of the person with the light switch of being straight or gay. I thought it was very interesting
ReplyDelete